Ailment Insults Part 2

I got a response back from Denise regarding my comment on her blog. She wrote:

Christine,

Thank you so very much for your comment! I hope you can discern from my blog that I would never intentionally inflict offense on an innocent person (indeed, I try to avoid offense even on guilty persons!).

My use of the word “hair lip” was completely misplaced. It is a word I remember from my youth — and to be honest I didn’t know it was the same as a cleft palate, nor did I know it was derogatory. My deepest apologies.

As to my reference to a cleft palate, I think you’ve helped me to make my point. A cleft palate *IS* so much more than psychological. So is transsexualism. Indeed, as you clearly point out, both can be life-threatening. But, in the majority of cases, in both instances, the patient can arguably survive in society without surgery. But why should we make them? We have the tools to correct this so-called defect (assuming, of course, that nature (or God) makes defects), so we should use our nature (or God) given talents to make the world a more manageable place for people so afflicted.

I wish you and your child the very best and I extend, again, my deepest apologies for any offense I’ve caused.

Denise

P.S. I also posted this response on my blog.

I still don’t really see the coorelation between transsexual surgery and cleft lip and palate. To me it’s a little like comparing cancer and heart disease. You can die from both, but that’s about where the similiarities end. However, I do see her point. There is so much more to both of these “defects” than lies on the surface. And only those who have been affected by either of these will fully understand the reasons behind the choice for surgery or even the effects of the ailments.

2 Comments »

  1. Denise Said,

    October 29, 2005 @ 12:56 am

    I don’t disagree with your analogy of heart disease and cancer. But, sometimes, those type of analogies are useful for helping others — not afflicted — to learn. No, it’s not perfect, but it helps to drive home the point that we have the tools to help people live useful, productive, healthy and happy lives — and we should use them.

  2. katie Said,

    July 16, 2010 @ 3:58 pm

    i found out yesterday that my daughter is going to be born with cleft lip… it runs in my family so there is nothing i could have done wrong to make this happen. i am fine with it its not going to make me love her any less or see her different than her big sister… but my boyfriend is taking it way harder than i could ever imagine and i dont know how to get it through to him that after a few surgeries we will hardly notice it and it will be like it never happened can i please get some advice on how to cope and how to explain this better to him please email me siamese_09js@yahoo.com please no spam

Leave a Comment